Littlest station gives us the 'sound' of Mars Express
On Wednesday night, we had some of the biggest ground stations in the world listening in on Mars Express, along with collaborative stations from the JIVE network. The professionals weren't the only people listening to our signal though - amateur radio operator Bertrand Pinel (F5PL) from near Castelnaudary, France, used his 3.5m dish throughout the flyby to listen to the signal from Mars Express.
Bertrand sent us a recording from his dish of the tone of the Mars Express signal, exactly what we would have heard if our ears were sensitive to the X-Band radio used by Mars Express! Hidden in this tone are tiny variations caused by the presence of Phobos and the MEX scientists are working hard right now to extract these from the recordings from the professional stations (Thanks, NASA!), which have the listening power necessary to detect these very fine variations.
Listen here to the whistle of Mars Express as it hurtles towards Phobos and consider that this signal was generated on Mars Express by a transmitter only slightly more powerful than a light bulb. This tiny signal travelled over 100 million kilometres and was picked up by Bertrand with his 3.5m dish - a truly remarkable achievement! Take a look after the jump for more details on Bertrand's station and the recording he made. -- Thomas
(Original mp3 file is here if playback box above doesn't work)
Bertrand's Recording
The recording of the tone of Mars Express shifts from high to low because, at the time of the recording, Mars Express was travelling away from the Earth with a speed of 39 000 km/hr - accelerating as it went - causing the change in tone. This is due to the Doppler effect and is exactly the same reason the sound of an ambulance siren changes as it passes you.
In the graph above, there is a sharp zig-zag at the start of the recording (the time starts at the bottom and goes to the top) - this is the effect of Mars Express catching onto the "sweep" of NASA's 70m ground station. This is a technique where the station on Earth varies its frequency to find one where Mars Express is listening. Then the Mars Express transmitter 'follows' this frequency from the ground, which is a much more stable frequency source than the one on board the spacecraft. This extreme stability is necessary to find the minute variations in the signal due to Phobos.
In the audio, the pitch of the Mars Express tone sometimes jumps from low to high: this is caused by Bertrand shifting the receiver to stay locked on the Mars Express frequency as it drifts due to the Doppler effect - exactly like re-tuning a station on your radio at home.
An 'Amateur' Deep Space Station
Bertrand's station in France (see him with it in this picture) was built through his own work and investment - but the equipment he operates is similar to the set-up of ESA's professional ESTRACK ground stations. There is community of dedicated amateurs around the world that build such stations to listen in on spacecraft at the farthest reaches of our Solar System. While these dishes aren't big enough to catch data from the missions, they can hear the faint tone of a spacecraft transmitting far away from Earth.
Bertrand's set-up is typical of one of these stations; he wrote to us some technical details of his station:
"The antenna is the key to success, along with much work and many hours to improve the signal quality!"
"The 3.5m dish is from an old CNES ground station near Toulouse that was decommissioned many years ago, it used to provide a 12Ghz satellite link for France Telecom. Much of the equipment attached to it is from discarded old hardware, such as an HP network analyzer and spectrum analyzer and 2 Rubidium atomic clocks."
As well as this Bertrand has all the equipment we are used to seeing on the ESTRACK ground stations, including a corrugated feed horn, polarizer and low-noise amplifier. All of this has been built, bought or given to Bertrand to make this station.
He's not the only one! In fact another amateur DSN member Wolfgang (DJ3QD), from Wöllstadt in Germany, also listened in on Mars Express with his 1.75m dish, but unfortunately lost the signal as we approached Phobos. For more details on amateur DSN activities and successes, check out their website: UHF-Satcom Amateur DSN.
The "Control Room" of Bertrand Pinel's 3.5m station during an earlier tracking of Mars Express.














02-04-2010 • 21:12:09
Thanks for You message about F5PL B.Pinel DSN, at first I am very sorry for that terrible delay with my answer...no Internet connection in my small
hamlet, even no road because end of winter season and pathway bedly blocked with havy snow...I planned to install my own Internet link by radio or satelite
but it will take another couple month or so. Any way I will do my best for that. Without normal Internet connection no go situation.
F5PL, Yes he doing goog job, sure really interested, ESA already fully informed me about him, but I do very appreciated for You Jeff for info end efforts.
Best Regards, 73
UA3MCJ Boris Nikitin
29 mar 2010
21-03-2010 • 17:19:49
Absolutely great effort.
Congratulations !!!!!
11-03-2010 • 10:41:33
Hello !
A lot of thanks for all these kind messages .
Many thanks too for ESA engineers for their trust about radio-amateur
work .
I loaded informations on Doppler Mars probes and a description of the equipement here on : amateur-DSN
Yahoo group .
Once again thanks you at all .
Regards and " 73s "
Bertrand Pinel
09-03-2010 • 00:58:42
A very good effort, Bertrand Pinel F5PL. Your efforts show what can be done, and show Amateur Radio as being more than 'talk'.
En français: Un effort très bon,
Bertrand Pinel F5PL. Vos efforts montrent ce qui peut être fait, et la radio amateur comme étant plus «parler».
09-03-2010 • 00:33:36
Mis felicitaciones por esta comunicacion de espacio profundo conseguida con un equipo personal.
Toda una azaña ..... enora buena desde España (amigo.)
08-03-2010 • 18:57:13
Super job Bertrand, impressionnant!! Ce genre d'article devrais etre plus diffusés en France afin de faire connaitre la diversité de notre activité. 73 Bertrand et merci pour tout.
Erik, F0DWP.
08-03-2010 • 13:00:22
Anther Great Milestone to Amateurs achievements, FB Pinel .73's
08-03-2010 • 09:09:32
There is always someone who doubts the accomplishments of others. I believe that this is a remarkable accomplishment, something I wish I had the capability to try. (Antenna restricted location, Damn!) It would be interesting to see a block diagram of the receiving equipment Bertrand was using. If I remember, someone was able to detect the signal from another sattelite that was leaving the solar system who was an amateur also.
09-03-2010 • 06:45:00
Quoting Russ H.:
'If I remember, someone was able to detect the signal from another sattelite that was leaving the solar system who was an amateur also.'
I was part of that team.. check out:
http://tinyurl.com/y9t4z7v
73s Achim Vollhardt, DH2VA
07-03-2010 • 20:48:44
'I don't think the pitch change is doppler effect. '
It is.. Earth rotates and this is the major component in the complete game..
07-03-2010 • 17:54:08
I don't think the pitch change is doppler effect. Pitch only changes when the relative speed of two objects change, and that is quite impossible at the speeds and distances we are talking about. So I would ask what is the real reason the pitch changes, maybe they made it do that on purpose to create a distinct signal..
08-03-2010 • 01:10:01
There is significant relative velocity between Earth and Mars. There is also the velocity due to the rotation of the earth (some 300m/s at the equator, good for 1ppm frequency shift, or 8kHz for the deep space X-band downlink at 8GHz), not to mention the orbital velocity of MEX around Mars (probably 1-10 km/sec). The curve shown is almost certainly Doppler.
07-03-2010 • 17:12:33
It's very exiting to hear this cosmic
sound of a planet from our planetary
system.
I hope that we hear more also from
another planets and stars in the future!Just go on for further cosmic activities!
I believe that we're going to make it happen!
07-03-2010 • 14:17:09
Great job! Truly impressive!
07-03-2010 • 06:41:38
This is a true amateur radio operator in the classic sense. Nice work, Mr. Pinel.
73,
KJ6BO
San Diego, CA, USA
11-03-2010 • 10:53:28
Hello Carl ,
Thank you for your value about the work .
happy to read messages from California .
All the work at memory of my friend Hoppy Hopkins AA6WI / N6BQ
passed with cancer on september 1999 .
Hoppy , working for Global Star net in a Toulouse station gave me the
10 Feet dish used for Mars tracking .
Once again , thanks you to California
people .
Bertrand Pinel F 5PL
07-03-2010 • 06:07:47
An outstanding achievement, both in capturing the signal and securing the equipment to catch it! My shout if you ever visit the states!
06-03-2010 • 00:13:33
¡ Realmente extraordinario !
(cada vez estamos mas cerca)
Felicitacions !
R.F.
05-03-2010 • 23:23:07
A Very-very nice setup and result!
Another proof that amateurs could do the job and have fun!